Sabil

Library · Where scholars differ

The start of Ramadan and the moon

“Fast when you see it and break the fast when you see it.” But does a moon sighted in another country count for everyone? And astronomical calculation?

  1. جمهور

    Hanafi, Maliki and Hanbali

    If the moon is reliably sighted in one place, most of their scholars consider it binding on other countries.

  2. شافعي

    Shafi'i

    Each region follows its own sighting, especially if it is far away.

  3. حساب

    Calculation

    Most classical scholars require sighting. Some contemporary fiqh councils accept astronomical calculation.

  4. جماعة

    In practice

    Fast and celebrate Eid with your local community. People's unity is a goal in itself.

To remember

That is why neighbouring countries may start Ramadan on different days. It is not an error: the criteria differ.

Source: Sahih al-Bukhari 1909 · Sahih Muslim 1087 · Ibn Rushd, Bidayat al-Mujtahid

Practise this lesson in the app

Test what you learned

Which school says each region follows its own sighting?Shafi'i · Hanafi · Hanbali

✓ Shafi'i

Two countries starting Ramadan on different days means one of them is in error.True · False

✓ False

What is recommended in practice?Fast with your local community · Start a day early just in case · Fast on your own

✓ Fast with your local community