The start of Ramadan and the moon
“Fast when you see it and break the fast when you see it.” But does a moon sighted in another country count for everyone? And astronomical calculation?
- جمهور
Hanafi, Maliki and Hanbali
If the moon is reliably sighted in one place, most of their scholars consider it binding on other countries.
- شافعي
Shafi'i
Each region follows its own sighting, especially if it is far away.
- حساب
Calculation
Most classical scholars require sighting. Some contemporary fiqh councils accept astronomical calculation.
- جماعة
In practice
Fast and celebrate Eid with your local community. People's unity is a goal in itself.
That is why neighbouring countries may start Ramadan on different days. It is not an error: the criteria differ.
Source: Sahih al-Bukhari 1909 · Sahih Muslim 1087 · Ibn Rushd, Bidayat al-Mujtahid
Practise this lesson in the app
Test what you learned
Which school says each region follows its own sighting?Shafi'i · Hanafi · Hanbali
✓ Shafi'i
Two countries starting Ramadan on different days means one of them is in error.True · False
✓ False
What is recommended in practice?Fast with your local community · Start a day early just in case · Fast on your own
✓ Fast with your local community