Sabil

Library · Where scholars differ

Why scholars differ

On the essentials all scholars agree. On some details there are several opinions, and that goes back to the Prophet's ﷺ companions.

  1. إجماع

    What is not debated

    The pillars of faith and of Islam, the five prayers, the fast of Ramadan or the prohibition of injustice admit no differing opinions.

  2. قريظة

    It happened with the companions

    The Prophet ﷺ said: “Let no one pray Asr except at Banu Qurayzah.” Some prayed on the way and others on arrival. He blamed none of them.

  3. أجران

    Two rewards or one

    If a scholar strives and is right he gets two rewards, and if he strives and is wrong he gets one.

  4. مذاهب

    The four schools

    Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i and Hanbali are recognised methods for understanding the texts. They differ over how a word is understood or which hadith reached them.

To remember

In this unit you will see each school's view. Follow that of your mosque or your teacher, and don't criticise those who follow another.

Source: Sahih al-Bukhari 946 and 7352 · Ibn Rushd, Bidayat al-Mujtahid

Practise this lesson in the app

Test what you learned

Scholars hold different opinions on whether the five prayers are obligatory.True · False

✓ False

What does a scholar who strives and is wrong receive?A sin · One reward · Nothing

✓ One reward

The Prophet ﷺ blamed the companions who understood his order differently.True · False

✓ False